[JEMMA]

I nodded more positively than I actually felt.

"Larry, please think about this very, very carefully. I want a totally honest answer, not what you think I want to hear. Beth is a very beautiful girl. I've held her. I've kissed her. I've eaten her pussy and enjoyed it. Would you like to go all the way with Beth? If you knew that we could still be lovers AND you could do it with Beth, would you like to have her?"

Thunderstruck doesn't come close to how I was feeling. I hadn't made love to any girl. Now I'm naked, my cock is playing patty-cake with her pussy, then Lynn asks me if I'd like to put my penis inside her sister.

[ Overload! Overload! Warning! Warning! Danger Will Robinson! ] Duuuuhh...

It took a long while for my hormones to let me communicate with my brain, though I finally got through. Eventually I replied.

"I want you to have my cherry, Lynn. I really think I love you. As for Beth, I've dreamed about both of you since I first got boners. Beth is a fox, she's fun, plus I like her a lot. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't dying to know what it would be like to make love to her. She is so much like you, but somehow I know it would feel different. Yet if it meant ruining things with you, I'd NEVER touch her."

Lynn melted me with another of her special smiles. She said, "Larry, you're too young for me to instantly fall hopelessly in love with, but you're making it very hard for me to remember that." Lynn held my face and kissed me with feeling. Mentally I vowed to keep making it hard for her to remember.

Lynn resumed speaking. "OK. Here's the plan. You and I will make love, but Beth and Jim will be here to watch us lose our virginity. Then you and I will quietly watch as Beth and Jim lose their cherries. If you guys are still able to tonight, we'll switch partners and all make love again.

Beth is as curious about you as you are about her. Watching Jim this past week has me dying to feel him inside me, I want you both. If we all have sex with each other, hopefully none of us will have anything to feel jealous about. If I do it with Jimmy, then Beth isn't the 'sick sister' that screwed her brother. Everything equal! No secrets! Also remember this, Beth and I have the right to be with each other any time we feel like it. What do you think? Can you handle all that without going Looney Tunes?"

"Could be you know me better than I do, Lynn. The way I've been feeling about you, I might have felt you were somehow all mine as soon as we made love. I'd never have thought of all the angles you girls did. I still think it might be a little difficult watching you doing it with Jim, but Beth is a pretty incredible consolation prize." I grinned.

"If we never fooled around with anyone one else, I guess there would be a lot we'd always wonder about. So it makes a weird kind of sense, and it should be a ton of fun. You can trust me to not be a jerk, or at to try my best."

Lynn hugged me tight. We held each other as minutes flew by. The discussion over, our bodies gradually became increasingly aware of each other. The room got warmer.

"Are you ready for me to bring in Beth and Jim if they're OK with everything?"

"Oh God yes, Lynn." I groaned. "I want you so much."

Lynn stood, heading for the door.

"Lynn." My voice stopped her.

"Sharing should be fun, but I'm so glad that you and I will always be each other's first."

I sat up as she returned to hold me a while longer. Following some unknown signal, we put a hand onto each other's genitals at the same moment. Our kiss continued; I massaged the area surrounding her clit; Lynn gripped my shaft, slowly pumping me. Our breathing quickened.

Just before we lost control, Lynn pulled away. "Beth really wants to watch me have sex my first time. If I don't get her in here NOW, she'll never get to see it." Lynn shot out the door.

[I really like this girl.] I agree, brain. 100%! ! !